Just the Facts on Hospital Price Regulation

As lawmakers seek to address rising health care costs, regulating hospital prices is an approach that is gaining traction.

To help policymakers understand the evidence on hospital price regulation, we synthesized the most credible peer-reviewed research in the latest installment of our Just the Facts series. The memo examines what happens to prices and spending when states regulate what hospitals are paid—and how hospitals respond.

Our analysis looked at twelve states that have adopted different approaches to hospital price regulation. Five states regulate prices in the broader commercial market; seven regulate what their state employee health plans pay hospitals. The evidence on these policies is still limited, but Rhode Island and Oregon offer the clearest findings.

Key Findings

  • Key Finding 1—The strongest evidence on price regulation that applies across the commercial market comes from Rhode Island. The state’s cap on hospital price growth in its fully insured commercial market has been in effect since 2010. The policy has lowered hospital prices by 9.1%, per-enrollee fee-for-service spending by 8.1%, and fully insured premiums by 6.5%, with no observable decline in quality measures through 2016. Hospitals responded to the growth caps primarily by reducing non-physician staffing rather than wages.

  • Key Finding 2—Oregon’s cap on what its state employee health plan pays hospitals has been in effect since 2019. The plan’s enrollees constitute 15% of the state’s commercially insured population. The cap lowered outpatient hospital prices by 25.4% and plan spending by an estimated 4% with no measurable decline in hospital finances, staffing, service lines, or patient experience. No study has yet measured the policy’s effect on clinical quality. The decrease in outpatient prices did induce an increase in outpatient care, which limited the effect of the policy on total spending.

Because evidence from states is limited, we also looked at research on what happens when Medicare changes its fee-for-service payment rates. This is where the deepest evidence exists on how hospitals respond to payment changes.

  • Key Finding 3—When Medicare raises its fee-for-service payment rates, hospitals treat more patients, adding beds and staff to do so. 
    ‍
  • Key Finding 4—When Medicare lowers its fee-for-service payment rates, hospitals respond by cutting operating costs, largely by reducing staffing. For certain conditions, there was suggestive evidence of reductions in clinical quality at hospitals with the largest payment cuts.

Read the full Just the Facts memo on hospital price regulation.

‍

More Commentary